dont take this as rumor, cos its not. its just an idea i had~ =D
so imagine if Scourge just randomly showed up in the Dark Forest?
Tigerstar would be getting ready to go into battle and the Dark Forest cats are battle ready, when Scourge suddenly steps out and everyones like “whaatttt in the name of-“
and Scourge would say something awesome and tlk about his revenge on Firestar and the Warrior clans.
now everyones prolly gonna be telling me “youre stupid. scourge doesnt/didnt believe in starclan.” or something or other like tht.

but what i realized is tht in the final battle with Bloodclan in ‘The Darkest Hour” after firestar just got back up after scourge had ‘killed’ him Scourge became uncertain for two split seconds..?

heres the part from the book:
“Scourge!” Firestar yowled. “Turn and face me!”
The small black cat whipped round, letting go of Cloudtail in his shock. “How…I killed you.”
“You did,” Firestar spat back at him. “But i am a leader with nine lives who fights along Starclan. Can you say as much?”
For the first time he thought he saw a flicker of uncertainty in Scourges cold eyes, and at last Firestar understood what Barley had told him.

tht ONE flicker of uncertainty could give Erin Hunter to bring Scourge back. i think she should because it would be a good plot, because 1) hed be trying to undermine Tigerstar and 2) more drama and action for the Clans.
what do you think?